Pigeon Cay is absolutely awesome. We travel a lot and must say this place is perfect for people who want seclusion, comfortable and clean accommodations, and miles of beach with just your footprints on it. The access to Bonefish is closer than most mailboxes.
If you want to sip a cold Kalik, stare into your ladies eyes on a romantic beach and eat lobster as big as a loaf of bread with out another tourist in sight this is the place. The owners are very accommodating and can work out just about anything for you. You just need to ask. However being a self sufficient traveler makes these kind of places what they are. Perfect.
All the Bungalows are clean, well kept, stocked with anything you would need to cook with, have comfy beds, AC (we did not need it) and seating to hang out in. The staff is very kind and helpful. You could be up at 8 am or noon and they would be waiting for you to stir before engaging you for breakfast or coffee. That is a nice touch. They are on your schedule not you on theirs.
We tried to cook as much as possible to keep the costs down I would recommend that. But that takes planning. We enjoyed a few meals made by the staff and they were fine. A bit pricy but your on an island in the middle of the ocean. So know what to expect and your will fall in love with this place. I give it a 9 out of 10 and my wife says its a cute 9.5. Do your home work, know what to expect, compare the other places and if you dont go here you will regret it. Trust me on this one.